This piece will appear in my new book of Essays And Still They Sing coming soon from Beaufort Books.
There comes a moment in grief when you begin to feel that you are being judged for it. People tell you that life goes on; that you need to stop looking back. I know that, because although I would never say it to anyone, I have often felt impatient with people who get into their problems and lie down in them. I have wanted to tell someone to get over it. In my own life, after various hard blows, including some difficult losses, I have managed to accept, to pick up the pieces of my life, and to move on. But it’s closing in on two years later, and I still have not gotten over Moses.
Life has a way of teaching us our faults.
His full name was Moses, Prince of Egypt. My husband and I argued about the name all the way to Iowa when we went to pick him up for the first time. I was insistent. It had to be Moses. It wasn’t a particularly religious choice. I had just watched too many reruns of The Ten Commandments, and wanted to be able to shake my head sadly at a naughty puppy and say “Oh, Moses, Moses, Moses.”
The name suited him. Despite having been bitten by one as a child, I had wanted a German Shepherd my whole life. I had even made a German Shepherd a character in my novels. Readers who met Moses always assumed that my character Elisabeth’s big dog, Rocco, was based on him. But Rocco was really an expression of longing. He came first. Then came Moses. Sometimes I have the sense that I willed him into being.
And he did, after all, lead us out of the wilderness. Our beloved Golden Retriever had died after a futile battle with lymphoma. Our other dog, Pete, was grieving, and our house felt empty, so we decided to sign up for the twelve to eighteen month waiting list for the perfect German Shepherd. Within twenty minutes we heard back: there had been a cancellation. Did we want a puppy on Saturday? I had the sense that it was meant to be: unplanned, the result of a series of unforeseeable events. And isn’t that what Fate is? The inevitable coming together of paths that seemed intended to diverge? Does it always have to be a human story?
From the beginning, I knew he would break my heart. I loved him too much. I can’t even explain exactly why. All I know is that there was a kind of destiny, an inevitability about him that I always felt. We belonged to each other. He was my soulmate. How to convey how much I loved him? How much I love him still? I know most people won’t think it normal. I can’t help that. It just was. It just is.
When he was only a few months old I sat in our living room, holding him on my lap, hugging him and whispering endearments. He was already too big to really fit, but I had my arms around him like a baby. My husband walked into the room and said casually: “You love that dog too much. You know he’s going to break your heart some day.” To the surprise of us both, I burst into wild sobs.
I was afraid of him at first. I’d never had a German Shepherd before, and I didn’t have confidence in how to handle him. By the time he came along I’d trained four dogs, and felt that I knew what I was doing. But when he chewed a shoe and I slapped the floor with it, scolding to show my displeasure, he avoided that spot in the kitchen for three days. That’s when I realized how delicate his sensibilities were. If I hurt his feelings, I could lose him forever.
But the moment that really frightened me was when, at 9 weeks, I tried to pull him off the bed he had no permission to be on. He growled and snarled at me, and I was struck with fear that I had a dragon in the house I could not control. I called my dog trainer that day, and begged her to let us start early. He earned his first obedience title at six months, and his second not long afterward. It required retrieval and he did not really take to retrieving, but he obliged me because that was what he did.
This is not to say that he was a tamed creature, tied to my will. Quite the contrary. Moses did things because he knew he should, and when I asked him to do something that was wrong for both of us, he would flat out refuse. One night, in the dead of a Wisconsin winter, I had an emergency call about my elderly mother. It was well below zero, and I had to meet the ambulance at the hospital. Moses knew I was upset, and he saw his job as being with me no matter what. But of course, he couldn’t sit outside in the car for hours in sub-zero temperatures. He followed me out to the car, refusing to let me leave without him, and trying to climb onto my lap. My husband gently put his hand on Moses’s collar to pull him away, and Moses turned and very meaningfully put his teeth on my husband’s arm. He did not bite; he nevertheless expressed his feelings very clearly. Moses knew his duty, and he was not easily dissuaded from it. I had to drive away from him, knowing we both felt betrayed by the separation.
I felt so much pride having this magnificent animal walk beside me. Moses loved going to the Fourth of July parade. The parade begins every year with a long line of historic fire engines, followed by the latest and most innovative, as the proud company of volunteer firefighters marches along. Moses would sing with the fire engines, a long, lovely howl that made people turn and smile. He would sit upright and bark at the three gun signal that began the parade, and he would duly accept the admiration of anyone who stopped to see him. When the parade was over, we would walk with the crowds down the street toward the park, and people would reach out their hands to touch him as he walked by, like Aslan in the resurrection.
There was a fierceness about Moses that is not in my other dogs. It lay beneath the surface, but it was right here for anyone to see. People respected Moses. As he deserved.
While we were remodeling our house, a five man insulation team arrived one morning without notice. My husband and I were at work, and only the carpenter, who adored Moses, was there. The insulators opened the door and walked in. According to the carpenter, who laughed while telling the story, Moses chased all five of them “screaming like girls” into the powder room, where they all crowded in, slamming the door behind them.
They called their manager while Moses waited outside the door.
Moses had a passion for butter. When he was young, he would steal whole sticks of it from the plate on a high shelf next to the stove. After we broke that habit, he sang for his butter, his paws dancing as he looked from the butter dish to my face and back, carefully explaining what he wanted.
More than anything else, Moses loved the lake. He was the first of our dogs brought up to swim, and he took to it immediately. But it wasn’t swimming that was his passion; it was splashing. His jumps to catch the water we splashed at him were stupendous. He leapt out of the water like a mythical beast, and his yearning to splash was relentless. If I were lazy and lounging on the dock, he would swim around the edge to me and paddle his paws to splash me, hoping to start a game. If I ignored him, he would urge me with increasingly louder moans of protest and pleading, splashing harder. He was impossible to resist.
There’s a Christina Perry song from a silly vampire movie that I used to sing to Moses. I remember the last time we were at the lake, a few months before he died. The music came on, and I whispered it to him, holding him in my arms, tears rolling down my face.
I’ve loved you for a thousand years.
I’ll love you for a thousand more.
I see now that I knew at some level it would be the last time we splashed together. Somehow, some part of me knew he was dying.
He had been in pain from an injured back, and it was slowing him down. I took him for exams. I asked every medical professional we saw—and there were a few—to reassure me that he would be all right. He’s not going to die, is he? He’ll be okay, won’t he? They all, with varying degrees of patience and curiosity assured me. Why would I even think that? He was only 7 years old. His back hurt. That was all.
But they were wrong. Somehow, in the deep connection Moses and I had with one another, I sensed that something, but it was nothing that showed up on any tests. It was just arthritis pain from a back injury, nothing more, I was told. Of course he didn’t feel well if his back hurt. We did acupuncture, chiropractic, and laser therapy. I took him for swimming therapy. He had varying levels of pain meds.
But he didn’t look right. His eyes were glassy. His fur seemed without luster. And all the while, the tumor was growing unseen, waiting to break his heart, and mine.
What hurts me most is that I wasn’t there. We had slipped away for three precious days to spend Christmas with our new baby granddaughter. While we were away, Moses had an upset tummy, but, like so many German Shepherds, he often did. We used to joke about such a big scary dog having “princess tummy”. We also live in the woods, and the dogs tend to eat things that require periodic doses of antibiotics.
He was sad when we left. He knew what suitcases meant. But we were unconcerned because he would be in his own home with his brothers and someone who cared for him. Over the course of our trip I spoke with the dog sitter multiple times. She was kind and reassuring. He wasn’t sick, but he was moping. He wasn’t eating, but he was drinking a lot of water. I was more worried about reassuring her than I was about Moses. We’d dealt with these tummy troubles before. I called the vet and arranged to pick up some antibiotics on the way home from the airport. We didn’t know he would already be there, cooling on a metal table.
Our dog sitter, never imagining we would go to the vet first, waited at our house, dreading our return. She didn’t want to tell us on the phone.
The one obligation of a soulmate is to be present when you die. But I wasn’t there. Instead, while we were in the air, Moses lay down next to our dog sitter, put his paw on her arm, looked into her eyes, and let out a long sigh. Then he died.
I know it sounds overly-dramatic, but I will never forgive myself. People have tried to tell me that he knew he shouldn’t die in front of me. I don’t buy it. He felt abandoned. He didn’t know where I was. I let him down. I, who sang love songs to him, who loved and trusted him, for whom he would have laid down his life, wasn’t there when he needed me most, and he died not knowing whether I would ever come back.
Looking back on that last year, I almost did the best I could. I didn’t miss his cues. The mistake I made was believing everyone—good people who didn’t know him as I did— who told me he was okay. I should have trusted my own heart. He was telling me, and I didn’t take his word for it.
Grief is one thing that never dies. I will be haunted by his loss forever. My only hope is that those insipid rainbow bridge poems are true, and that someday he will run to me, and I will be able to kneel down, gather him into my arms, and whisper my love into those big fierce ears.
Oh, Moses, Moses, Moses.
58 thoughts on “On Moses”
Thank you for sharing him with us, we still miss him too.
I hear you. I feel you. I understand. I sit here in tears.
I just saw this – I thought it was just me – and I know its not just me – Artika has been gone a year and I cannot stop mourning her…
I’m sorry. It gets easier, but it never goes away.
Dear Ms. Riordan:
A few years ago, I started a thank you note to you. You sent people a copy of your book North of the Tension Line. I was typing it on the computer. Thank you notes should be handwritten. I used to be so good at writing thank you notes and writing to be in general. Well, I never wrote and have felt embarrassed. I read the book when lockdown started and thoroughly enjoyed it. I like books and mystery/crime shows that focus on the characters, some quirky and most likeable. Yes, I did think of Moses whenever Rocco was mentioned. That was who I envisioned Rocco was even though Moses came after Rocco. Thank you for introducing me to your writing.
I liked your essay about Moses. You mentioned you were afraid of him at first. That is how I would be with a German Shepherd.
I follow you and Mr. Sykes on Twitter. I enjoy your photos of the dogs, and I cried when Moses and Pete died. My golden retriever Darby died in September of 2019 of a heart tumor. She was 14 years old. On New Year’s Eve, I had my other golden retriever put to sleep. He had fluid in the stomach area and the vet said it meant something serious. He was 14 years old. He celebrated his birthday in November. I didn’t realize I loved him as much as I did until he died. I had Darby as a puppy, and she was my angel. Mason had belonged to my nephew. Darby and I puppy sat him a couple of times. His name was Mason. He later went to live with my sister, and he stayed with Darby and I when were pet sitting her dogs. I asked if Mason could stay with us. He wasn’t Darby. I loved Darby. I liked Mason.
When I lost Darby, it took me a bit to realize Mason had lost a friend. We took care of each other, and I made sure he was number one. I never left him. Darby and I had maybe been separated 15 days at most during her 14 years. Mason was 3 or 5 years old when he came to live with me, and I was never away from him.
Before Darby, I had a springer spaniel/poodle mix. She was more springer spaniel. Cindy came into my life when I was 13. She had taught me about loyalty. Cindy died four days after her 16th birthday. It was 18 years before Darby entered my life. I felt it would be disloyal to Cindy, and I also wasn’t able to have a dog. Darby was my sister’s puppy. I was pet sitting for a week. That week ended up being 14 years. I never asked if I could keep her, but truth is I fell in love with her when I first saw her.
I never felt Darby and Mason were loyal. I always felt they’d drop me in a heartbeat. I am an introvert. Darby and Mason were extroverts who loved meeting new people. I accepted that. I knew they would never protect me. They barked and sounded scary until I opened the door. Then they turned into the welcoming committee. I loved them because they were friendly and patient with me.
When Darby died, I took her to the emergency vet and had a note written. I knew I would cry so I handed the receptionist a note. When I was with the vet, I was okay talking with him and he explained what was wrong with her. I chose, however, not to be present when he put her to sleep. I later read stuff about how awful a person must be to not be there when their dog needed them most. I have felt guilty ever since. Mason was always number two until Darby died. I made sure I stayed with him until the end. I felt I owed him. The emergency vet Mason and I saw told me to forget what everybody says and do what is best for me. Like I said, I felt I owed him, so I was present.
Oh, I say he was number two, but I tried to treat them the same. My parents used to always say about my sister and I, that they treated us the same. If you do for one, you do for the other. Treated us equal, and always remember that regarding my niece and nephew and my sister’s grandkids.
He was good company and a good dog. I loved him more than I thought.
I will still hang my head in shame for not sending you a handwritten thank you note immediately upon receiving your book. Thank you for the book, and I do intend to read more. I enjoy your writing, and I enjoy following life with Auggie and Eli. Looking forward to hearing if you go to Turkey this year to visit the cab driver.